What is Butterfinger Bonanza?
Butterfinger Bonanza is listed in our ice cream cakes guide. The useful starting point is its base, mix-ins and serving format—those details explain what you are ordering more clearly than the product name alone.
Peanut butter is a defining part of this combination. Compare whether it appears as a sauce, candy inclusion or spread; these formats affect the texture and make the allergen discussion especially important.
Select-store option: this product appears among local favorites or pies on the official menu. A listing is not confirmation that every store offers it.
Butterfinger Bonanza prices and sizes
A current price for this exact item and serving was not verified in the researched store menu. Choose your own location on the official ordering site or ask the store for a quote. A similar-looking product or a standard scoop price should not be substituted for this item.
The standard cake guide describes small rounds serving up to 8 and large rounds serving up to 14. Other shapes and petite cakes may be offered, but the store must confirm the available format, design and pickup lead time for this cake.
Calories and serving information
| Listed serving / size | Serving weight | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Petite; 2 servings per product | 202 g | 660 |
| Sm Round; 8 servings per product | 155 g | 520 |
| Lrg Round; 14 servings per product | 147 g | 480 |
| Sm Rectangle; 25 servings per product | 148 g | 480 |
| Lrg Rectangle; 40 servings per product | 130 g | 410 |
The figures above come from the official nutrition chart, reviewed November 11, 2026. They apply to the listed standard build and serving weight. For multi-serving products, the calorie figure is per stated serving, not the entire cake, pie or pack. Recipe updates and substitutions can change the result.
Ingredients, allergens and changes
The short build description is not a complete ingredient or allergen statement. Review the official ingredient lists and allergen chart, then discuss your needs with the store. Shared preparation surfaces and tools mean that removing an ingredient does not establish an allergen-free product. Flavor names alone do not identify every ingredient.
How to order Butterfinger Bonanza
- Open the official ordering website and select the store you will use.
- Find the exact product and review the available size or pack.
- Check whether substitutions, toppings, cones or personalization are permitted and whether they add a charge.
- Confirm the total and pickup time with that store before completing your order.
For celebrations, ask about lead time and how the frozen product should be transported. Ready-now stock and a custom pre-order can have different availability and customization rules. Arrange freezer space before pickup.
What else should you compare?
Start with the Ice Cream Cakes landing page for the full group. Related choices include A Cheesecake Named Desire, Cake Batter Confetti, Chocolate Chipper.
Butterfinger Bonanza compared with related choices
The table below compares the listed recipes in the same menu family. Start with the base or filling, then look at the additions: two desserts can share chocolate, cake or fruit while using different combinations. The price column preserves the researched product’s own quote; a missing quote is not replaced with a similar item’s price.
| Item guide | Listed ingredients / format | Local price example | Calorie context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Butterfinger Bonanza | Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream with Butterfinger wrapped in fluffy Peanut Butter Frosting | Check local price | 410–660 cal / serving |
| OREO Cookies & Cream Extreme | Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Ice Cream with GOLDEN OREO Cookies and Cake Batter Ice Cream with OREO Cookies wrapped in fluffy OREO Cookie Frosting | From $40.99 | 400–450 cal / serving |
| Cake Batter Layers | Eight luscious layers of Cake Batter Ice Cream, moist Yellow Cake, Cookie Dough and Chocolate Shavings wrapped in fluffy Cake Batter Frosting and topped with Fudge | Check local price | Check exact serving |
| A Cheesecake Named Desire | Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cheesecake Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Pie Crust wrapped in fluffy Raspberry Frosting | From $40.99 | 320–570 cal / serving |
For Butterfinger Bonanza, the listed combination is Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream with Butterfinger wrapped in fluffy Peanut Butter Frosting. Compare that build with OREO Cookies & Cream Extreme, Cake Batter Layers, A Cheesecake Named Desire. These are recipe comparisons, not a personal tasting or a ranking. If a particular component is your reason for choosing this dessert, confirm that component is available before accepting a substitution.
Before choosing a size or adding extras
Keep the item name and serving together when comparing totals. The starting price shown above applies to the format named in its price note. It does not automatically cover the largest size, every cone, extra toppings or delivery. Review the options after selecting your restaurant, since the ordering screen can change when you switch stores or fulfillment methods.
For a group, count the portions you actually need before comparing a shared dessert with individual orders. A whole cake, a quart and an individual cup use different serving conventions. The cup-size guide and cake serving guide explain those differences. For a customized build, use the official ingredient information for the final combination rather than treating the standard nutrition row as an exact new total.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Butterfinger Bonanza cost?
The exact current quote is not verified here. Contact your selected store for the product and size you want.
Can I customize this item?
Options differ by product and store. Check the current ordering panel; changing ingredients can affect price, nutrition and allergens.
Is it available at every Cold Stone location?
No nationwide availability is implied. The official menu and local stock can differ, especially for seasonal flavors, local favorites and celebration products.
What ingredients are listed for Butterfinger Bonanza?
Layers of moist Yellow Cake and Cake Batter Ice Cream with Butterfinger wrapped in fluffy Peanut Butter Frosting. The official ingredient statement provides more detail than a flavor name.
Which alternatives should I compare?
Start with OREO Cookies & Cream Extreme, Cake Batter Layers, A Cheesecake Named Desire. Compare their listed base, additions and serving format.
Does the displayed price include every extra?
No. Use the named size and local price note, then check any additional mix-ins, cone, customization or delivery charges at checkout.
Are these calories for my customized order?
The values describe the stated standard build or serving range. Substitutions and additions can change the total; consult the calorie and serving guide.
Can I use a different store’s quote?
Use it only as a comparison. A final price must come from the restaurant and order channel you select.
Where should I confirm stock before traveling?
Use the official Cold Stone Creamery website to find your store and its ordering information.
How do I report an outdated detail?
Send the page reference and correction through our contact page. Include the store and serving when the correction concerns a price.
Is this the right choice for your order?
Use Butterfinger Bonanza as a starting point if its listed flavor combination and format match what you want. Compare the serving and any additions alongside the price, then use your local store menu for the final choice. The complete menu directory makes it easy to move between categories without confusing a cup, a drink and a multi-serving dessert.
Sources and review notes
Reviewed November 11, 2026. Ingredient facts and menu values are source-based; flavor comparisons are editorial interpretations of the listed build, not claims of a personal tasting. Read our pricing and editorial approach.